I suppose I have to say something. I’m very angry, including at myself for not being able to do anything about this. I did do a bunch of low-impact volunteer gigs at the polls and early voting. Nothing strenuous. One back to school night. ( I was handing out sample ballots there, one clown refused to take one, said this is not a place for politics, then he walked over to the Republican, took their sample ballot, and chatted him up for a while. This is why I tend to avoid human contact.)
I was on a flight back home from Miami to visit the little one, who will be a mother next year. I stupidly booked a flight that connected in Charlotte, NC, and nearly killed myself running from one gate to another, in one big ass airport. A big F-U to American Airlines. As we landed, the pilot asked those who did not need to make a connecting flight to remain seated, so the rest of us could get off more quickly. Not one damn person stayed on the plane. It would surprise me to learn that they all had connecting flights.
That’s why the human race is doomed. I always like watching apocalypse movies to see how the characters doom themselves by rejecting simple forms of cooperation.
Chris Hayes made a key point in the MSNBC post-election babble, that throughout the social-democracies of Western Europe, we can observe the flight of the working class from its prior loyalties on the Left. That tells me it’s not a matter of how Kamala should have campaigned but didn’t. One can always find arguable errors in a big campaign, after the dust has settled, especially after a defeat. Of course the party establishment will blame the left. It’s what they have done since the ‘80s.
If we believed in the merits of a traditional meat-and-potatoes approach as the key missing dimension of Democratic Party politics, Sherrod Brown and Jon Tester would be a senators next year. I doubt they were seen talking about pronouns.
I don’t follow or analyze polls. As far as that goes, the dominant thing for me that emerges is the shift in the Latino vote. It reminds me of a book that made a big impression — “How the Irish Became White” — by Noel Ignatiev. In Miami we talked to a Cuban cab driver who said the newest wave of Cuban immigrants were lazy bums, accustomed to moral indolence due to living under Communism. Isn’t it the same with every immigrant group? Everyone who gets in wants to pull up the ladder to block newer arrivals.
Here in Loudoun County, VA, the big thing is preventing further population growth. And that’s the Democrats. The liberals in their huge houses on two-acre lots. Meanwhile housing and rental costs keep the Eastern part of the county under financial stress. Loudoun is the fastest growing part of the state, very well-off due to the preponderance of tech jobs and Federal retirees with pensions. Virginia stayed blue this time around, but the housing problem does not bode well for the party in one of its key strongholds.
If class politics is over, I really don’t know where to go. My only radical organizational affiliation — Democratic Socialists of America — has been tap-dancing around the question (for them it’s a question) of who should be president and control the U.S. Congress.
Politics has sort of been my life’s work, and now I’m adrift. Maybe I’ll get myself one of those electric keyboards and learn piano.
We both knew this at Rutgers at age 20:
The United States is the most dominant imperial power in history. Its wealth/power elites maintain its position (and their position) acting through two political parties and a duopolistic electoral system. Among those elites there are differing ideas about the most effective orientation. The two parties reflect that. A conservative wing of the bourgeoisie advocates for implementing policies that are straightforwardly nationalistic, pro-market, and pro-wealth accumulation. The Republican Party is their vehicle. A liberal wing thinks it’s wiser to foster stability through geopolitical alliance relations and, domestically, through placation of the masses via the welfare-statist policies of the Democratic Party.
There are continual debates “at the top” about these differing orientations. The elites compete in trying to disseminate more appealing messaging to the masses. Neither seems to “win out” long-term. For over 150 years the Republicans and Democrats have traded place in regard to presidential administrations. For over 150 years our national legislature has been about evenly divided between Republicans and Democrats. So those parties obviously are responsible for the state of things . . . the obscene levels of inequality, the militarism, inadequate housing and healthcare coverage, the unfair taxation system, political dominance by the mega-corporations, destruction of ecological habitat, the climate chaos, the withering of local community life. That’s the essential status quo and it doesn’t change all so much under the jurisdiction of one party or the other. They are both creatures of hypermodern industrial capitalism. That extant status quo is unsatisfactory for the masses of people; they express dissatisfaction by voting out the incumbents on a regular basis, so we see oscillating administration of the system. At one time the Republicans were a little better. Nowadays the Democrats are a little better. Sure, Nixon, Reagan, Bush, and Trump were “the greater evil,” but, really, not by all so much relatively, in regard to the systemic essentials.
There will be a breakthrough point after which our electoral system will open up. From what happened with Perot you can see how it can happen. This year Kennedy could have advanced from 15% support to 20% support and made a significant impact. We should be laying the groundwork for true multi-party democracy rather than continuing to foster delusions about the Democratic Party, rather than continuing to suffer disappointment decade after decade.
“If class politics is over, I really don’t know where to go.”
Right.
Something happened, Max. It happened during the ’80s.
I’ve gone through two major head changes. Like you, I grew up a middle-class Jewish kid in the suburbs who believed in the American Dream. My becoming a Marxist in college was a head change that upset my whole family.
But I started reading Murray Bookchin during the 1980s. Over a period of ten years I went through a second really major head change: from Red to Green.
Marxism is wrong in its fundamentals and just doesn’t conform to reality. So it leads its adherents into a dead-end: “I really don’t know where to go.”
Here’s where to go:
https://discussion.dsausa.org/t/what-ever-happened-to-the-peoples-party/37270/7